FEEM working papers "Note di lavoro"
Date: 3/11/2020

Mothballing in a Duopoly: Evidence from a (Shale) Oil Market

Nicola Comincioli (University of Brescia, Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei); Verena Hagspiel (Norwegian University of Science and Technology); Peter M. Kort (Tilburg University); Francesco Menoncin (Università di Brescia); Raffaele Miniaci (University of Brescia); Sergio Vergalli (University of Brescia, Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei)
JEL n.: L12, L71, Q41
Keywords: Crude Oil, Shale Oil, Mothballing, OPEC, Output Game


The mothballing option has been studied in the literature, but mainly in decision theoretic frameworks. This paper looks at it from a strategic point of view and applies it to an incumbent-entrant framework. In particular, based on the recent strategic interactions between OPEC and the shale oil industry, we conduct a case study where the incumbent OPEC is a exible producer that competes with a representative shale oil firm. Upon entry, the latter produces a fixed amount but it can apply the mothballing option in times of low demand. Our main results are threefold. First, we find that under low demand uncertainty, the mothballing option has a negative effect on the value of the entrant. Second, a large market share of the entrant will stimulate mothballing, caused by a so-called squeeze strategy of the incumbent. Third, our empirical analysis of the (shale) oil market learns that a higher demand elasticity induces mothballing.


Suggested citation: Comincioli, N., V. Hagspiel, P. M. Kort, F. Menoncin, R. Miniaci, S. Vergalli, (2020), 'Mothballing in a Duopoly: Evidence from a (Shale) Oil Market', Nota di Lavoro 18.2020, Milano, Italy: Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei

Download file
Download file

FEEM Newsletter & Update

Subscribe to stay connected.

Your data will be processed by FEEM - Eni Enrico Mattei Foundation - Data Controller - to receive the Foundation's Newsletter & Update via e-mail. To send the requested information, the Data Controller uses e-mail sending service providers established in the U.S.A .: for this, your consent to the transfer of your email address to the U.S.A. is required, without which it will not be possible to comply with your request. We invite you to consult the complete information to obtain detailed information to protect your rights.