FEEM working papers "Note di lavoro"
Date: 26/11/2020

Do Voters Choose Better Politicians than Political Parties? Evidence from a Natural Experiment in Italy

Maria Rosaria Alfano (University of Campania); Anna Laura Baraldi (University of Campania); Erasmo Papagni (University of Campania)
JEL n.: D72, K16, C21
Keywords: Ballot Structure, Preference Vote, Politicans’ Quality, Human Capital


This work analyses the effect of the two preference voting systems – proportional system with blocked lists of candidates vs proportional system with open list of candidates - on the quality of politicians. The exogenous variation in the Italian Parliament electoral system (Law n. 270/2005) - which marked the switch from an open to a closed list - allows us implement a Difference-in- Differences approach to compare the change in politicians' quality (as their education level) across the treatment group (the Parliamentarians) and the control group (the regional councillors) of politicians before and after the electoral reform is enforced. We find that the introduction of the reform lowered the politicians' ability. The result is common for Senators and Deputies and it is robust to the inclusion of control variables and to the restriction of treatment group to pastappointed Parliamentarians. This evidence suggests that voters are able to choose more qualifying politicians than political parties and it may be an argument in favor the re-introduction, in the electoral law, of preference voting schemes.


Suggested citation: M. R. Alfano, L. Baraldi, E. Papagni, (2020), 'Do Voters Choose Better Politicians than Political Parties? Evidence from a Natural Experiment in Italy', Nota di Lavoro 24.2020, Milano, Italy: Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei

Download file
Download PDF file

FEEM Newsletter & Update

Subscribe to stay connected.

Your personal data will be processed by Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei. – data Controller – with the aim of emailing the FEEM newsletter & Update. The use of Your email address is necessary for the implementation of the newsletter service. You are invited to read the Privacy Policy in order to obtain additional information about the protection of Your rights.

This Website uses technical cookies and cookie analytics, as well as “third party” profiling cookies.
If you close this banner or you decide to continue navigating on this Website, you express consent to the use of cookies. If you need additional information or you wish to express selective choices on the use of cookies, please refer to the   Cookie PolicyI agree